4.2/5 - (39 votes)

You have probably seen the claim that money stops making people happier once they earn around $75,000 a year. That number came from real research, but later studies, including one written by former rivals working together, tell a more useful story about money and day-to-day mood.

Where the $75,000 figure came from

In 2010, psychologist Daniel Kahneman and economist Angus Deaton analyzed more than 450,000 answers to a daily Gallup survey of US residents. Their study in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences separated two things people often lump together: how you rate your life overall when you think about it, and how you actually feel during an ordinary day.

Life ratings kept climbing with income. Daily emotions also rose with income, but the authors reported “no further progress beyond an annual income of ~$75,000.” That line traveled far. What got lost is that $75,000 was simply the middle of the survey’s $60,000 to $90,000 income bracket, not a precisely measured cutoff.

A 2018 analysis of the Gallup World Poll, covering more than 1.7 million people, published in Nature Human Behaviour by researchers at Purdue University and the University of Virginia, also found “satiation” points: about $95,000 for life evaluation and $60,000 to $75,000 for emotional well-being worldwide, with later thresholds in wealthier regions.

Then a bigger dataset found no plateau

In 2021, Matthew Killingsworth of the University of Pennsylvania took a different approach. Instead of asking people to remember yesterday, his app pinged them on their phones and asked how they felt right then. His study collected more than 1.7 million real-time reports from 33,391 employed US adults.

See also  Nostalgia can loosen your grip on money, six experiments suggest

In that data, average happiness kept rising with income well above $75,000, with no visible leveling off. Two respected studies now pointed in opposite directions.

What happened when the rivals teamed up

Rather than trade rebuttals, Killingsworth and Kahneman ran what researchers call an adversarial collaboration, with psychologist Barbara Mellers as facilitator. They reanalyzed Killingsworth’s data together, and their 2023 paper found that both sides were partly right.

  • For the least happy people, roughly the bottom 15 to 20 percent, happiness rose quickly with income and then flattened at around $100,000 a year (household income, before taxes).
  • For most people, happiness kept rising with income with no clear ceiling.
  • For the happiest group, the link with income actually grew stronger above $100,000.

The authors suggest the plateau may mark the point “beyond which the miseries that remain are not alleviated by high income.” In plain terms, money eases the problems money can fix, like rent stress or an unexpected bill, but not the ones it can’t.

What this means on a student budget

A few cautions first. These studies looked at adults, mostly working, not college students specifically (the median participant in the 2021 data was 33). They are correlational, so they show that income and happiness move together, not that a raise will make any one person happier. The 2023 analysis has itself drawn a published critique on exactly that point. And income explains only part of the difference in how people feel: Kahneman and Deaton found that health, caregiving and loneliness were relatively stronger predictors of daily emotions.

See also  Are canned fruits and vegetables worth it on a student budget?

Still, one pattern holds across all of this work: the relationship is steepest at lower incomes. Kahneman and Deaton also noted that low income makes life’s hard moments, such as illness or being alone, feel more painful. For most students, that means small, practical moves that reduce money stress, like a starter emergency fund, knowing what your financial aid office can help with, or avoiding high-interest debt, may matter more to day-to-day mood than any big number you hope to earn later.

If money worries are affecting your sleep, grades or mood, your campus counseling center and financial aid office are good places to start. Both deal with this more often than you might think.

Quick answers

Is there a salary where happiness stops increasing?

Not for most people, according to the 2023 joint analysis. A plateau around $100,000 appeared only among the least happy group.

Does more money guarantee more happiness?

No. The studies describe averages across thousands of people. Health, relationships and other factors also play a large role in how people feel day to day.