4.8/5 - (54 votes)

Plenty of employers say they cannot find the right people, and plenty of new graduates say they cannot find a job that uses their degree. Both can be true at once, and the numbers on the graduate side are worth knowing before senior year.

What underemployment actually means

Being underemployed is not the same as being unemployed. Economists use the word for a college graduate who has a job, but in an occupation that typically does not require a bachelor’s degree. A marketing grad working the front desk of a gym would count. So would a biology grad running a cash register.

The Federal Reserve Bank of New York tracks this every quarter in its Labor Market for Recent College Graduates series, which looks at degree holders aged 22 to 27. In its update for the second quarter of 2026, the bank described conditions for recent grads as challenging: unemployment stayed at about 5.6 percent, and underemployment edged up to 42 percent.

The first job tends to set the path

A larger study goes further by following graduates over time. In Talent Disrupted, a February 2024 report from Strada Education Foundation and the Burning Glass Institute, researchers combined online career histories from tens of millions of workers with census microdata. They focused on people whose highest credential is a bachelor’s degree.

Their headline finding: 52 percent of graduates were underemployed one year after graduation, and 45 percent still were a decade later. The two sources measure different groups in different ways, which is why the New York Fed figure is lower, but both point in the same direction.

See also  Cost per wear: the budget math that can change how you buy clothes

The report also found that the starting point matters a lot:

  • Of graduates who started in a college-level job, 79 percent were still in one five years later.
  • Of those who started out underemployed, 73 percent were still underemployed ten years after college.
  • A recent grad in a college-level job typically earned about 88 percent more than someone with only a high school diploma. An underemployed grad earned only about 25 percent more.

That gap matters most for students carrying loans, since loan payments come out of whatever the first job pays.

It is not a life sentence, though. The New York Fed notes that many underemployed graduates work in non-college jobs that are fairly skilled and well paid, and move into better roles once they have some work experience.

What was linked to better odds

The Talent Disrupted team looked at major, school selectivity, demographics, location and internships. Two factors explained more of the difference than the rest.

Internships

After controlling for gender, race and ethnicity, and characteristics of the college, graduates with at least one internship had 48.5 percent lower odds of being underemployed than those with none. The authors found the link held across fields of study. This is an association, not proof that an internship causes a better outcome, since students who land internships may differ in other ways too.

Field of study

Majors heavy in quantitative reasoning, such as computer science, engineering, math, finance and accounting, had underemployment rates under 37 percent. Education and health programs such as nursing were also low. Fields like public safety, recreation and wellness, and general business (marketing, for example) were at 57 percent or higher. The report also warns that STEM is not a guarantee: life sciences grads, biology included, tended to face higher rates.

See also  Pet influencer ads made people willing to pay more, study finds

Where you live played a role too, with underemployment varying a lot from state to state, but less than major or internships did.

Practical moves while you are still in school

  • Plan for at least one internship before graduation, paid if possible, and talk to your campus career center early in the process.
  • Pair a broad major with a concrete skill, like data analysis, a second language or a technical minor, that shows up clearly on job postings in your field.
  • Treat the first job search seriously. Given how sticky the first role can be, a few extra months of searching for a degree-level position may be worth weighing against taking the first offer, if your budget allows it.
  • Look beyond your campus town. Since outcomes vary by state, being open to relocating or to remote roles can widen your options.

None of this guarantees a particular job. But the data suggests the choices you make before graduation, especially getting real work experience, are among the ones that matter most.