When the same Instagram ad featured a cat instead of a woman, people said they would pay about 43% more for the product. A study in the Journal of Advertising Research says the reason is simple: we tend to see animals as sincere, and that feeling can follow us all the way to checkout.
If your feed is full of dogs, cats and the occasional very confident rabbit, some of those posts are ads. Brands now hire “petfluencers,” pets with their own accounts and real followings, to sell everything from snacks to socks. For students scrolling between classes on a tight budget, it helps to know how that pitch works.
What the researchers tested
The paper, “Petfluencers, the fur-mula for sincere endorsements”, comes from marketing researchers at the University of Strathclyde, the University of Louisville and the University of Edinburgh. It combines four studies.
- A real ad test on Instagram. Using Meta’s A/B testing tool, the team ran two nearly identical peanut butter ads for four days to US users over 18. One showed a dog’s paws, the other a man’s hands. The pet version reached a similar audience (18,224 vs. 17,613 people) but got 18 post engagements instead of 6, at about a third of the cost per engagement.
- A wine ad experiment. 150 online participants saw the same Instagram post, voiced either by a cat or by a woman. Those who saw the cat said they would pay an average of $58.08 for a case of wine, compared with $40.57 for the human version.
- A sincerity test. 201 participants were first nudged to think about sincerity or insincerity. The pet advantage showed up only when sincerity was on their minds, which points to sincerity as the driver.
- A student sample. 185 undergraduates at a large US university, average age about 22, saw a sock ad from a pet account and stated what they would pay, with a real prize draw tied to their answers.
Why a cat feels more trustworthy than a person
The explanation is not cuteness alone. In a pretest, the pet and human influencers did not differ in attractiveness or cuteness. What changed was how sincere the endorser seemed. When people suspect a human influencer is in it for money or fame, the message loses some weight. A cat has no visible agenda, so the same words land differently.
The authors also found that the effect depends on the viewer. Among the students, those who naturally tend to give animals human thoughts and feelings were willing to pay more after seeing a message framed around today rather than the future. In plain terms, the more you see your feed’s pets as little people, the more a pet ad can move you.
Of course, a pet does not write its own captions. Someone runs the account, picks the brand deal and gets paid, in cash or in free products.
Keep in mind what the study can and cannot say
- Most of the results come from controlled experiments with made-up posts, not from real influencer accounts. The authors themselves call for research using data from actual influencers.
- Willingness to pay is what people say they would spend, not what they actually spent at a store.
- The field test was small in absolute numbers (18 vs. 6 engagements), even if the difference was statistically significant.
- Three of the four studies used products that have nothing to do with pets (wine and socks). The authors say they did not test how a good or poor fit between pet and product changes the effect.
How to keep a cute ad out of your budget
Under the Federal Trade Commission’s influencer guidance, anyone with a financial, personal or family tie to a brand should disclose it clearly, and free products count. The FTC page does not mention pet accounts specifically, but the person behind the account is the one with the brand relationship. In the UK, the Advertising Standards Authority has published rules written for pet influencer accounts.
A few habits can help you spot the pitch:
- Look for the label. Words like “ad,” “sponsored” or “paid partnership” mean the post is marketing, whether a dog or a person is in it.
- Separate the pet from the product. Ask whether you would want the item if a stranger had posted it. A charming cat tells you nothing about wine, socks or headphones.
- Check the price somewhere else first. Before you tap through, compare the item on another site or in a store. If you still want it the next day, the decision is more likely yours and less likely the ad’s.
- Notice “right now” wording. The study suggests present-focused messages can work especially well for animal lovers, which is exactly when a pause is useful.
None of this means you have to unfollow your favorite cat. Enjoying the content is fine. Just remember that a sincere-looking face can still be part of a paid campaign.

