4.9/5 - (59 votes)

Feeling out of place in your first months of college is common, and research suggests it is worth taking seriously. A new long-term study of students in Australia found that how connected they felt to their school was the only school-related factor tied to better well-being two years later.

Student-to-teacher ratios, type of school and funding did not show that link. Relationships did. Combined with a series of experiments run at American colleges, the findings point to a simple idea: belonging is not a soft extra, it is part of how students cope and stay on track.

What the Australian study tracked

Researchers at the Black Dog Institute and the University of New South Wales followed 1,548 students from 35 schools in New South Wales, starting in Year 8 (average age just under 14) and checking in again two years later. Their results appear in npj Mental Health Research.

The team compared three layers of factors:

  • School-level features, such as location, public or private status, and administrative data on the student body
  • Staff views of their school’s culture and how much it promoted well-being
  • Students’ own ratings of the school climate and of how connected they felt to the school community

At a single point in time, students who rated their school climate and connectedness higher reported better well-being and less distress. Students from more advantaged backgrounds also reported better well-being. But over two years, only student-rated connectedness was associated with higher well-being later on. None of the school-level features were linked to well-being or distress at either point.

See also  Tips didn't change students' phone habits, but weekly goals did

Why this matters beyond high school

The Australian students were young teens, not college students, so the results cannot simply be copied onto a freshman dorm. American research on college students points in a similar direction, though.

In a randomized trial at a selective US university, published in Science in 2011, psychologists Gregory Walton and Geoffrey Cohen gave first-year students a short exercise. It presented worries about fitting in as common and temporary, something many students feel early on and that tends to fade. The trial was small (92 students). Over three years, the exercise raised the grade point average of Black students compared with control groups and halved the achievement gap with white students. Those students also reported better health and well-being and fewer doctor visits three years later.

A much larger follow-up, also published in Science in 2023, tested an online version of the exercise with 26,911 students at 22 institutions. Taken before college in under 30 minutes, it increased the rate at which students completed their first year as full-time students, especially in groups that have historically progressed at lower rates. There was an important catch: it only worked at colleges where those students actually had opportunities to belong.

Small ways to build connection on campus

None of these studies tested a checklist of tips, and no single step will fix loneliness. Still, the research suggests that relationships with peers and with staff are what count, so a few low-cost moves are worth trying:

  • Go to office hours once early in the semester, even with a simple question, so at least one instructor knows your name
  • Join one recurring group (a club, intramural team, study group or campus job) rather than sampling events once
  • Talk to your RA, an advisor or a peer mentor if your college offers one
  • Remember that early doubts about fitting in are widely shared, which was the core message of the US experiments
See also  Found a bat in your dorm room? What the CDC says you should do

The limits to keep in mind

The Australian study is observational. It shows that connectedness and later well-being go together, not that one causes the other: students who already feel better may also find it easier to connect. The US trials measured grades, persistence and self-reported health, not mental health diagnoses.

If a sense of isolation comes with persistent low mood, anxiety or trouble functioning, your campus counseling or health center is the right place to start. In a crisis in the US, you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.