4.3/5 - (37 votes)

Plenty of college students answer to a manager, whether at a campus library desk, a coffee shop or a warehouse shift. Most of those bosses are fine. Some are not, and decades of workplace research describe what a truly harmful supervisor looks like and what it costs the people who work for them.

A 400-year-old case study in bad management

A new paper by Clive Boddy, an associate professor of management at Anglia Ruskin University in the UK, looks at an extreme example. In the Asian Journal of Business Ethics, he assesses Jeronimus Cornelisz, a merchant working for the Dutch East India Company in the 1620s. After the company ship Batavia wrecked off Western Australia in 1629, Cornelisz took control of the stranded survivors, and about 100 of them were killed under his rule.

Boddy scored his behavior against a framework used to study what researchers call “corporate psychopaths.” According to Anglia Ruskin University, Cornelisz showed all ten traits on the list, including using charm to win trust, surrounding himself with loyal supporters, removing challengers, turning rivals against each other, creating a climate of fear and dodging responsibility when things went wrong. Boddy calls the episode “effectively a natural experiment in leadership.”

It is worth keeping this in proportion. This is a reading of historical records, not a clinical diagnosis, and your shift supervisor is not a 17th-century mutineer. But the behaviors on that list are the same ones employees describe in modern workplaces.

How common is a bad boss at work

Work is a normal part of college in the US. According to the National Center for Education Statistics, 40% of full-time undergraduates and 74% of part-time undergraduates had a job in 2020.

See also  Amazon shut down Mechanical Turk: what it means for student side gigs

Mistreatment on the job is not rare either. In a 2021 national survey run for the Workplace Bullying Institute, an advocacy group, by Zogby Analytics, 30% of 1,215 American adults said they had been bullied at work, and 65% of the people named as bullies were bosses. The survey covered adults in general, not students specifically.

What an abusive supervisor does to the people under them

Organizational researchers use the term “abusive supervision” for sustained hostile behavior from a boss, verbal or nonverbal, such as ridicule, public put-downs, the silent treatment or taking credit for your work. In a widely cited study in the Academy of Management Journal, Bennett Tepper found that employees who saw their supervisors as more abusive were more likely to quit. Those who stayed reported lower job and life satisfaction, more conflict between work and family, and more psychological distress.

The study also found that a sense of unfair treatment explained most of those effects. Its design was correlational, so it shows a strong link rather than proof of cause, but it matches what many workers report: the damage comes less from one bad day than from a pattern.

What you can do if it sounds familiar

  • Look for a pattern, not a single moment. A stressed manager who snaps once is different from someone who belittles, plays favorites or blames others week after week.
  • Keep simple notes. Write down dates, what was said and who was there. Notes help if you decide to raise the issue later.
  • Use the channels that exist. For a campus job, the student employment office or human resources can step in. Off campus, a manager above your boss or HR is the usual route.
  • Know the legal line. Harassment tied to race, sex, religion, disability or other protected traits is covered by federal law enforced by the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission. General rudeness usually is not, which is why internal reporting matters.
  • Remember a student job is replaceable. Your career center can help you find another position, and leaving a harmful job is a reasonable choice.
See also  Cost per wear: the budget math that can change how you buy clothes

If the situation is affecting your sleep, mood or classes, your campus counseling center is a good place to talk it through. The research is clear on one point: a toxic boss is a problem with the job, not a sign that something is wrong with you.