Your SAT score followed you into college, but how much does it actually say about how you will do there? The latest research gives a surprisingly split answer, and the type of campus you are on matters a lot.
The SAT turned 100 this year, and the debate around it is as lively as ever. More than 2 million students in the high school class of 2025 took the test at least once, according to the College Board, the first time the number has passed that mark since 2020. At the same time, most colleges still let applicants apply without scores. So if you are already enrolled, a fair question is whether that number should shape how you see your own chances.
At highly selective colleges, scores carried weight
A research brief from Opportunity Insights (John Friedman, Bruce Sacerdote and Michele Tine, January 2024) looked at admissions records and first-year grades at several Ivy-Plus colleges for students who entered between 2017 and 2022.
Comparing students with the same high school grades and similar backgrounds, those with a perfect SAT (1600) or ACT (36) earned a first-year college GPA about 0.43 points higher than those with a 1200 SAT or a 25 ACT. High school GPA, by contrast, barely moved the needle at those schools: a 4.0 student ended up less than 0.1 point ahead of a 3.2 student in college GPA. Students who applied without submitting a score performed, on average, like students with an SAT of about 1307.
That kind of evidence is part of why several elite schools brought back their testing requirement.
At broad-access public universities, grades won
A different picture comes from a March 2026 NBER working paper led by Theodore Joyce, an economist at the City University of New York. The team used records from the 2010 to 2019 first-year cohorts at the eleven senior colleges of a large urban public university system, ranging from very competitive to non-competitive.
Their conclusion runs the other way. A one-standard-deviation rise in high school GPA was four to six times more predictive of graduating within six years than the same rise in SAT scores. When the researchers forecast outcomes for 2020 to 2024 using high school GPA alone, they lost relatively little accuracy compared with models that also used test scores. The paper has not yet been peer reviewed.
It lines up with an earlier study by Elaine Allensworth and Kallie Clark of the University of Chicago, published in Educational Researcher in 2020. Following 55,084 Chicago Public Schools graduates who went straight to a four-year college, they found high school GPA was about five times stronger than ACT scores at predicting college graduation. “The bottom line is that high school grades are powerful tools for gauging students’ readiness for college,” Allensworth said when the study came out.
Why the two findings can both be true
These studies measure different things in different places. The Ivy-Plus brief focuses on first-year GPA among students who almost all arrived with excellent grades, so high school GPA has little room to separate them. The public university studies look at graduation across a much wider range of students, where steady work over four years of high school seems to say more about finishing a degree.
Both are correlations. Neither shows that a score or a GPA causes anything, and neither can predict what one particular student will do.
What this means if you are already in college
- Your score is not a verdict. At most campuses, the research suggests that grades built over years of coursework track with graduation better than a single test day.
- Applied test-optional to a very selective school? The Ivy-Plus data describe averages, not you. If first-semester courses feel steep, tutoring centers, office hours and academic advisors exist for exactly that, and you do not need to wait until you are struggling to use them.
- Grades still matter after admission. Many scholarships and programs look at your college GPA, so the routines you build now carry forward.
If school stress is weighing on you, your campus advising office or counseling center is a good place to talk it through.

