4.6/5 - (60 votes)

If you are signing up for Spanish 101 or Korean 101 at 19, you may have heard that the window for learning a language closed years ago. A study of nearly 670,000 people suggests the real picture is more encouraging, and more specific, than that.

The research, published in the journal Cognition by Joshua Hartshorne, Joshua Tenenbaum and Steven Pinker, is one of the largest ever on how age affects language learning. Here is what it found, what it did not test, and how it applies to a college language class.

A grammar quiz that went viral

To get a sample big enough to answer the question, the researchers built a short online grammar quiz that guessed each player’s native language and dialect. People shared it widely on social media, and the team ended up with data from 669,498 native and non-native English speakers.

Most earlier studies only compared how well people who started at different ages ended up speaking. This team used a computer model to separate three things: a person’s current age, the age at which they were first exposed to English, and how many years of experience they had. That let them estimate how the underlying ability to learn grammar changes over a lifetime.

The result: the ability to learn grammar stayed high until about 17.4 years old, then declined steadily. That cutoff is much later than many researchers had assumed.

Native-like grammar is a different question

The same data also looked at how good learners eventually became. People who began learning by roughly 10 to 12 years old tended to reach the same final level as native bilinguals. People who started later generally did not reach native-like scores on the quiz.

See also  Can pink noise during sleep boost your memory? What research says

Why the gap between 17 and 10 to 12? Learning a language takes a very long time. In the study, even native speakers kept improving until around age 30, and both native and non-native immersion learners needed about 30 years of experience to reach their peak. Someone who starts at 15 still has a strong learning ability, but not enough years before it starts to decline to fully catch up.

The authors are clear on one point that often gets lost: the debate was never about whether adults can learn a new language. They obviously can. In fact, some non-native immersion learners in the data who started in their late 20s eventually outscored the youngest native speakers in the sample, who were children.

What the study did not measure

Keep a few limits in mind before drawing conclusions about your own class:

  • The quiz measured grammar only. The authors note that pronunciation and vocabulary may follow a different timeline.
  • Everyone was tested on English, not on the languages most American students take.
  • Players chose to take an online quiz, so they were not a random sample of the population.
  • Reaching native-like grammar is not the usual goal of a college language requirement. Being able to read, talk and get by is a much more realistic target, and the study does not say adults are bad at that.

How college students are choosing languages

Fewer students are taking languages at all. In the Modern Language Association’s fall 2021 census of 2,455 US colleges and universities, enrollments in languages other than English fell 16.6% from 2016, to 1,182,562. That was the largest drop in the history of the census.

See also  Can't focus on long class readings? What attention research suggests

Spanish remained by far the most studied language, with 584,453 enrollments, followed by French and American Sign Language. Among the 15 most commonly taught languages, only three grew: Korean jumped 38.3%, from 13,936 to 19,270 enrollments, while ASL and Biblical Hebrew posted smaller gains. German had the steepest decline, at 33.6%.

Practical takeaways for your next language class

  • Do not treat age as a reason to skip it. The research points to a slower path to perfect grammar after the teen years, not to a closed door.
  • Think in years, not semesters. If even native speakers keep improving into their late 20s, two semesters is a starting point. Plan how you will keep practicing after the requirement ends.
  • Look for exposure outside class. The study’s strongest learners were immersion learners. Conversation tables, language houses, study abroad programs and media in the target language are ways to add real use.
  • Pick a language you have a reason to use. A link to your family, your future job or your community will make years of practice easier to sustain.

If a learning difference makes language courses especially hard for you, your campus disability services or academic advising office can explain what support and options your school offers.