Ask almost anyone how they would react if a boss or interviewer crossed a line, and they will describe a confident, immediate “no.” Psychology research suggests the real moment rarely goes that way, and knowing why can help you plan ahead for a campus job, a lab position or your first internship.
What people imagine versus what they actually do
In a study published in the Journal of Social Issues, psychologists Julie Woodzicka and Marianne LaFrance compared two groups of women. The first group, 197 respondents, read a description of a job interview in which a male interviewer asks inappropriate questions, such as whether the applicant has a boyfriend and whether people find her desirable. They were asked how they would respond.
Their answers were bold. 68% said they would refuse to answer at least one of the harassing questions, and more than a quarter imagined telling the interviewer off or walking out.
The second group went through what they believed was a real interview for a research assistant job. Among the 25 women who were asked the same harassing questions, the result was striking: not one of them refused to answer. About half simply answered the question as asked. Some did ask the interviewer why he wanted to know, but most of them waited until the very end of the interview to do it. No one left, and no one reported him to a supervisor.
Fear, not anger
The emotions were different too. Only 2% of the women imagining the scene expected to feel afraid; anger was the reaction they predicted most often. In the real interviews, 40% of the women who were harassed described some level of fear, and only 16% reported feeling angry. The more afraid an interviewee felt, the less likely she was to confront the interviewer.
That makes sense once you remember what was at stake: they wanted the job. Pushing back would have meant risking it.
Why we overestimate our own courage
Researchers call this gap the “illusion of courage.” In a set of three experiments, Leaf Van Boven and his colleagues found that people consistently overestimate how boldly they will act in embarrassing situations when those situations feel distant or hypothetical. In a calm state, it is hard to predict how much anxiety will shape your behavior once you are actually in the room.
The other side often doesn’t notice
The misunderstanding runs in both directions. In two preregistered studies, Vanessa Bohns and Lauren DeVincent at Cornell University surveyed 942 STEM graduate students about real unwanted romantic advances and ran an experiment with 385 participants using a coworker scenario. People who made the advances consistently underestimated how uncomfortable it was for the other person to say no, and how much that discomfort changed the other person’s behavior. Women in the graduate student survey were more than twice as likely as men to report being on the receiving end.
According to Cornell’s summary of the research, 52% of targets tried to avoid the person after turning them down, while only 7% of the people who made the advance thought so. The researchers warn that this blind spot can lead someone to read a polite, evasive answer as interest:
“Underestimating the role of discomfort in driving targets’ reluctance to say ‘no’ may lead suitors to misattribute this reluctance to genuine romantic interest.”
What this means for students
None of these studies says that staying quiet means agreeing. They show the opposite: silence in front of someone with power over you is often a sign of fear, not consent. If you froze or played along in a situation like this, the research suggests that is a very common reaction, not a personal failure.
A few practical steps can help before you need them:
- Know who to contact. Every college that receives federal funding must have a Title IX coordinator, who handles sexual harassment involving students, including student employees.
- Find the confidential options. Campus counseling centers can usually talk with you privately before you decide whether to report anything.
- Write things down. Notes with dates, what was said and who was present can matter later, even if you are not sure yet what you want to do.
- Look out for others. If you see a classmate or coworker in an awkward spot, a simple interruption or a check-in afterward can make it easier for them.
Keep in mind the limits of this research. The real interview study involved only 25 women who were asked the harassing questions, and the Cornell surveys relied on people’s memories. Still, the pattern across studies is consistent. If you are dealing with a situation like this, your school’s Title IX office or counseling center is the right place to start.

