4.7/5 - (55 votes)

Career panels, alumni talks and “day in the life” videos are supposed to open doors. A huge randomized trial in Ecuador found they can also close some: after watching short interviews with young scientists and entrepreneurs, high school seniors became less likely to pick a STEM major in college.

What the researchers actually tested

The study, published in Nature Human Behaviour, followed 29,243 final-year students (average age 17) at 813 technical high schools in Ecuador. Half of the schools were randomly assigned to the role model program, while the other half watched regular educational TV content from the country’s Ministry of Education.

Students in the program sat through two 30-minute lessons built from interview clips with ten scientists and ten entrepreneurs, all young Ecuadorians aged 24 to 34. They talked about their typical day, why they chose their path, the skills it takes and the advice they would give a teenager. The lineup included an electrical engineer who built a device for people with limited vision, a molecular biologist working on cancer and founders of businesses in coffee, tourism and baby clothing.

Delivery was cheap and reliable. According to the research team, 94% of students watched at least 19 of the 20 planned segments, at a cost of $0.86 per student. The researchers then used government records to see what those students actually enrolled in after graduation, not just what they said they wanted.

The result went the opposite way

The goal was to spark interest in science and high-growth entrepreneurship. Instead, among girls who went on to college, the videos cut STEM enrollment by 5.0 percentage points, an 18% drop compared with the control group, and raised business enrollment by 5.7 points. Business majors in the sample were already mostly female, so the gap widened.

See also  Changing majors early in college is far more common than you think

Boys who entered college moved away from STEM too, by 4.9 percentage points (a 7% drop, since far more boys chose STEM to begin with: 68.6% of college-going boys in the control group, versus 28.5% of girls). They shifted mostly toward fields such as agriculture, humanities and the arts.

Seeing more role models of their own gender did not change the outcome much, for either girls or boys.

Why the comparison may have backfired

To understand what happened, the team asked 110 students to watch the clips closely and rate each speaker. The scientists came across as making their field look more challenging, needing more skills and more study. They were also rated as having less passion and charisma, as less similar to the viewers and as reinforcing stereotypes more than the entrepreneurs. Economist David McKenzie, one of the authors, noted in a World Bank blog post that the “harder” impression “can reflect the reality of these careers.”

The authors’ reading: earlier studies usually put students in front of one inspiring person, whose story could stick. Seeing many people from two fields side by side seems to push students to compare the paths instead, and steer away from the one that looks tougher.

What this does and doesn’t tell you

This was a study of high school seniors in Ecuador, during pandemic-era remote schooling, so it does not show that the same thing would happen at an American campus career fair. It also does not say whether switching away from STEM was a good or bad move for those students. McKenzie put it plainly: “it is very difficult to say whether changes in what students study are welfare enhancing at either the individual or societal level.”

What it does show is that a couple of short videos can measurably change a real decision, so first impressions of a field deserve a second look before they settle your major.

See also  Are women more emotionally intelligent? What a big review found

How to use career stories without being steered by them

  • Separate the person from the field. A speaker who seems awkward or uncharismatic tells you little about whether you would enjoy the work.
  • Treat “this looks hard” as a question, not an answer. Ask what the difficulty actually involves (more math, longer training, lab hours) and whether that is a trade-off you would accept.
  • Test the field directly. An intro course, a club, a research assistant spot or an informational interview gives you more to go on than a polished clip.
  • Talk it through. Your campus academic advising and career center can help you weigh options, especially if you are deciding between very different majors.